For a pastor considering me for membership
I left my marriage because I was being abused. My church declared me guilty without hearing me.
This is what happened between September 12 and November 20, 2026, told plainly, with every claim tied to the written record. The full evidence packet is at the bottom of this page.
My statement
What I need you to know
I am an ordained teaching elder. I married Shey Valentin on September 12, 2026, intending to stay married for life. Within weeks I was living under constant verbal and emotional abuse. There was peace in that home on one condition only: that I surrender every part of myself to her control. Whenever I did not, I was punished with hours of accusation, belittling, and contempt.
I did not walk away at the first sign of trouble. I wrote to her that I loved her and was not asking for a separation or a divorce. I offered counseling. She refused it. I gave in to her demands, slept in a bed that causes me serious pain, and signed her lease. It bought a day or two of peace. When I finally understood that nothing I surrendered would stop the abuse, I left on October 8.
The day I left, I called my pastor. When he answered four days later, his first question was whether I had any sins to confess. From that point on, my pastor and the Session of Reformed Faith Presbyterian Church treated me as guilty. They ordered me to stop my court case before looking at my evidence. They never answered my arguments from Scripture. They wrote a formal charge declaring that I had "committed this sin" before any trial was held.
I am not above correction, and I have never refused to be shown my sin from Scripture. What I will not do is accept a verdict that was reached before anyone heard me. I am asking you to read what follows, look at the evidence, and judge for yourself.
The marriage
Peace had one price: my surrender
This is the short version. My full firsthand testimony gives every incident in detail.
Before we married, Shey knew about my back condition, which makes lying flat in a bed seriously painful and is why I have slept in a recliner for years. She knew about my nerve pain from shingles, my work as a caregiver, my care for my mother, and my responsibilities to my sons. We agreed I would divide my time between her home and my mother's while we worked toward a home of our own. That understanding did not survive the first weeks.
Every ordinary duty became an offense
I had paid about $7,000 for the wedding trip and was working 11- and 12-hour shifts, available only through September, to recover. Shey demanded that I stay at her home every night and give her all my free time. Work, rest, and nights at my mother's home after long shifts were treated as betrayals. In her home I was corrected over turning on a fan, leaving on a light, or moving an object.
One night, after a 12-hour shift and my evening medication, I missed a message about a door lock. I could not safely drive, so I offered to take an Uber to her. She wrote back, "I literally told you not to get an Uber," and accused me of failing her. The next day, September 27, I gave up a workday I could not afford, drove to her, and spent the day comforting her and apologizing.
In the middle of fights she ordered me out of her house more than once. Each time I gave in, and each time she did not follow through.
Attacked for the attention she had declined
I came home exhausted, showered, and invited her to spend time with me. She declined. Later she came upstairs angry and accused me of neglecting her. When I reminded her that I had asked, she said she would not beg for my attention. I explained and apologized until I could only go quiet.
I wrote to save the marriage
Because every spoken attempt turned into a confrontation, I wrote to her. I asked for basic room to live as her husband: to work, rest, have preferences, sometimes disagree, and have my physical limitations believed. I wrote:
"I am not asking for a separation. I am not asking for a divorce. I am not ending our marriage… I want our marriage. I want a life with you."My letter to Shey, September 30, 2026 (packet page 12)
I offered counseling together. Her answers that night are in her own words below: "I don't need counseling," "You're an asshole," "I don't ever wanna see your fucking face again," and an ultimatum to be in her bed the next night "or it's done."
I gave in
That evening I drove back to her home to talk in person. It became another hours-long confrontation. To save the marriage I gave up the boundaries I had asked for. I apologized for how I had delivered the letter, stayed with her every night, slept in her bed through the pain, and signed onto her lease.
My pain was called a lie
On the evening of October 1, I lay on top of the covers beside her to comfort her, and she accused me of choking her. I had not. I got up at once and apologized that she was frightened.
After midnight the pain of lying flat was more than I could bear, so I went downstairs to the recliner. I had spent hours of that day in prayer, asking God whether there was any way to save my marriage. She came down and attacked me for hours. She called me a liar for saying I was in pain, called me "avoidant," and said I most likely had multiple personality disorder. She told me to return to her bed or the marriage was over. I went back to the bed.
Peace only through total compliance
For two days I gave her my undivided attention, and there was peace. On October 4, while we moved a mattress in the heat, a condition she knew makes me ill, I began sweating and struggling to breathe. She said I was being dramatic and putting on a show, ordered me inside like a child, and berated me for about three hours. On October 5 and 6 I gave up my own time and preferences entirely to keep the peace.
Humiliated for caring for my sons
I used my one weekday off to prepare urgent, notarized custody papers for my sons, whose mother was moving them out of state. Shey was angry that I was not giving her my attention. When I finished, she spent hours humiliating me and attacking my manhood:
"You clearly have no idea how to be a man, I can teach you how to be a man, ohhhh but I am not trying to emasculate you."Spoken to me on October 7, as I distinctly recall it
That night I understood that no amount of surrender would stop the abuse.
I left
I waited until she left for work. She had ordered me out in the middle of fights before, and I feared that telling her face to face would set off another hours-long confrontation and keep me from leaving with my belongings. I packed, returned her key, left a note, and went to my mother's home. I then sent her written explanations of why I left. That evening she came to my mother's door demanding to be let in. I offered to put her things on the porch, then offered to have an officer present. She answered: "A call to the police shows up on your record as well just so you know." I called the police anyway, and she collected her belongings with officers present.
Her words, September 30 to October 1
What she wrote after I asked to be treated with respect
These are Shey's replies to the letter in which I told her I loved her and wanted our marriage. Each is shown in her own text messages. Tap a screenshot to see it full size.


Long messages can appear shortened in a phone's conversation view, so some screenshots may not show a message in full. They preserve what was on screen when they were taken. Page numbers refer to the evidence packet.
After I left
The attacks did not stop when I was gone
"Thank you for doing me the favor of leaving it's like the trash took itself out goodbye and good riddance."Shey's email to me, October 10, 2026 (packet page 25)
She sent me Scripture describing "abusive, slanderous, brutal" people with the instruction to "have nothing to do with such people." She sent my adult son videos portraying me as a narcissistic, "avoidant" husband who abandons his wife, and similar material reached my brother, his wife, my uncle, and my best friend. She threatened to sue me, told me my ministry was finished, and threatened to report me to my elders over money.

This was not an unhappy marriage that I chose to end. It was control, enforced by threats to end the marriage and by hours of verbal attack whenever I did not submit, and it continued after I left.
How the church handled it
A verdict first, a trial afterward
I was a member of Reformed Faith Presbyterian Church in Tennessee, in the Christ Reformed Presbyterian Church denomination, under the oversight of Pastor Jim Thornton and the Session (the board of elders).
I called my pastor. He asked for a confession.
I called Pastor Thornton on October 8, the day I left. On October 12 he texted that he was "not ready to talk to you on the phone." I told him I was seeking an annulment and "just wanted to talk to my friend and pastor." His first reply:
"Very sad situation. Do you have any confession of sins to make?"Pastor Thornton, October 12 (packet page 33)
I asked what sin he meant. He answered with a list: that I had "dishonored Christ," "have not been honest," "jumped into a marriage and now want a divorce," and that he had "to wonder if you are not in thick darkness." He asked "On what grounds?" but did not wait for the answer. I asked him to separate what he knew from what he assumed and to name the specific sins with their basis in fact and Scripture. He never did. A week later he wrote only that "you were not deeply concerned when I told you to repent."
He also claimed I had been "relieved" when my first wife filed for divorce. In March I had written to him and the Session that I did "not desire this, nor do I approve of it" (packet page 5).
I explained and offered my evidence
The Session wrote that my plans raised "serious concerns." The same day I answered at length: what happened, why I left, why I filed for annulment. I wrote that I had correspondence supporting my account and would provide it. Because chronic pain and medication make live questioning very hard for me, I asked to be examined in writing (packet page 42).
Ordered to stop, without reading the evidence
The next day, without asking to see that evidence, the Session wrote that it found "no evidence in your correspondence that meets the biblical threshold" and ruled:
"We now require of you that you not pursue through civil courts the termination of the marriage."Session letter dated October 21 (packet page 46)
For Scripture, it pointed me to two chapters of the Westminster Confession and Numbers 30. It never addressed 1 Corinthians 7:15 or whether abuse is a form of desertion.
I answered from Scripture. They never replied to it.
I sent a detailed answer from Scripture, the Westminster Confession, and the denomination's own Book of Church Order (packet page 48). No elder ever responded to a single argument in it.
Charged, with the verdict already written
The Session sent a formal charge. Before any trial, it states:
"Mr. Hoke has committed this sin against the peace, unity and purity of the Church, and the honor and majesty of the Lord Jesus Christ."Charge and Specifications, November 6 (packet page 60)
Its second count makes my disagreement with the Session the offense: that after the Session found my reasoning inadequate, I "refused to follow the Session's counsel." The only witnesses it lists are my own letters and texts. The cover letter admits the Session never reviewed the evidence I offered, saying it had understood my offer as mere corroboration.
That day I pleaded not guilty and answered the charge in writing. My answer went to the wrong address by mistake. When I learned this on November 18, I explained it and sent the full answer to the Session (packet pages 63–68).
Cited to trial
The Session called me to a trial by video on December 9, saying the denomination's rules make no provision for a written defense (packet page 69). I will not take part in a trial whose verdict was written into the charge before it began, with no one to speak on my behalf.
What was never done
- No elder examined the evidence I offered before ordering me to stop.
- No elder answered my exegesis of 1 Corinthians 7:15 or my argument that abuse is desertion.
- No one investigated or heard from anyone. The charge lists only my own letters as witnesses.
- The charge declared me guilty before the trial was scheduled.
"He who answers a matter before he hears it, it is folly and shame to him."Proverbs 18:13
Why Scripture permitted me to leave
The argument the Session never answered
In 1 Corinthians 7:15 Paul teaches that when a spouse deserts the marriage, the believer "is not under bondage in such cases." The Westminster Confession (24.6) likewise recognizes "willful desertion as can no way be remedied" as grounds for ending a marriage.
Desertion is more than walking out the door. A spouse who drives the other out through cruelty has already forsaken the covenant, even while still living in the house. This is not a new idea. The Puritan William Ames wrote in 1632: "if one party drive away the other with great fierceness and cruelty, there is cause of desertion, and he is to be reputed the deserter." John Frame makes the same argument in "Spousal Abuse: Grounds for Divorce?"
The Sixth Commandment, "You shall not murder," requires us to protect life, including our own (Westminster Larger Catechism 135). Leaving a home where I was being abused was obedience to God, not rebellion against Him.
The evidence
The full evidence packet
Every email in this case, copied word for word from my Gmail and in date order, along with Pastor Thornton's text messages and the complete 245-page archive of text-message screenshots between Shey and me. It is long and meant for reference, so use the contents below to go straight to what you need.
Open the evidence packet (PDF, 316 pages)
- Timeline p. 2
- Part 1: My March letters on my first marriage p. 4
- Part 2: The Session's August letter and my reply p. 8
- My September 30 letter to Shey p. 12
- Shey's emails, including "the trash took itself out" pp. 16–31
- My October 10 explanation of why I left p. 19
- Part 4: Pastor Thornton's text messages p. 32
- The Session's October 20 order p. 46
- My October 22 answer from Scripture p. 48
- The charge and the Session's November 6 letter pp. 59–61
- My not-guilty plea and answer p. 63
- The November 19 trial citation p. 69
- Part 6: Text-message archive pp. 71–316
- Shey's replies to my September 30 letter pp. 188–205
Zoom links and passcodes have been removed. Long text messages can appear shortened in a phone's conversation view; tapping the bubble on my phone opens the full message, and the full September 30 letter is reproduced on page 12.


















